Fishers Island Real Estate - Mystic Isle Realty, Inc.

Overlooking the 9th Green at Hay Harbor

Water views, 6+Brs, Great Cond. Garage Apt.

West End Overlooking the 9th Green at Hay Harbor 6+BR’s, water views, great condition and location Located on .57 acres in one of the most desirable areas on the Island, this special property has a tremendous amount ...

View this property >>

Isabella Beach Road - Revised Price

3 BR, 1.88 acres, Water Views

ISABELLA BEACH ROAD CONTEMPORARY HOME WITH GREAT WATER VIEWS This three bedroom, three bath home was built approximately thirty years ago to take advantage of the wonderful water views that this 1.88 acre building...

View this property >>

East End and Near Isabella Beach

Private, water views, 4BR's

Isabella Beach Road Panoramic water views Situated on approximately 2 acres near Isabella Beach, this well maintained and modernized four bedroom home enjoys grand water views of both sides of the Island ...

View this property >>

Brillig - Updated Price

The Estate of Henry Luce III

Brillig Henry Luce III Estate Fishers Island, NY duPont Registry Listing This striking waterfront estate has been thoughtfully designed to take advantage of one of the most compelling waterfront sites on the Island. Light and...

View this property >>

East End, Classic FI Estate

Dock, Beach, Garden, Observatory

Magnificent Property This elegant 5000 +/-sq.ft. home, situated on 11.4 acres, has a private beach, a 120-ft. dock and more than 600 feet of frontage onWest Harbor. Much of the main house enjoys commanding views l...

View this property >>

East End Contemporary House

East End, 2.5 acres Great Condition

Spectacular East End Contemporary This architecturally significant contemporary home is located on 2.5 acres and is in absolutely first class condition. Originally built in the early 1990's, this stylish yet warm and c...

View this property >>

Fabulous views of the Sound

West End, Beach, Dock

West End Modern 3,500 sq. ft. HouseViews of The Dumplings and Flat Hammock2.2 acres, Private Beach and Dock Located on the West End this fabulous property has many of the best features Fishers has to offer. The modern, six y...

View this property >>

Barleyfield

East End and near the Club

BARLEYFIELD FISHERS ISLAND, NEW YORK This very manageable and well maintained home enjoys one of the premier locations at the East End of the Island. Located within walking distance of the Big Club, with ele...

View this property >>

Brooks Point Road

Six bedrooms, pool, good condition

Brooks Point Road This is a very unique property located on 2.9 acres off the Brooks Point road. This fantastic six bedroom house has a nice formal dining room and a spacious living room with a fireplace and distant views of ...

View this property >>

The Hilt House

In Town, 1.5 acres

This classic, shingled 5 bedroom cottage is located on 1.5 private acres near the center of town. A deep 2-sided porch on fieldstone foundation provides spacious outdoor recreation areas on sunny and rainy days, an...

View this property >>

Two lots on the East End with a Beach

200 feet of Waterfront on the North Side

A Rare Opportunity Two Undeveloped East End Lots On the North Shore of the Island This is a special opportunity to purchase two adjoining lots that are located between the driving range and Chocomount Beach on the Nort...

View this property >>

West End Five Bedrooms

Winterized and on Winthrop Drive

WEST END This five bedroom winterized home is located on approximately half an acre on secluded and tree lined Winthrop Drive. The 2800 sq. foot house includes a renovated eat in country kitchen with modern appliances ...

View this property >>

Sale Pending

Located on approximately .90 of an acre of high land within easy walking distance of the village green, this winterized 5 bedrooms, 3-bath property includes a nice sized living room with fireplace, separate dining room, offi...

View this property >>

SOLD

On West Harbor with a Dock Located on West Harbor this fully renovated house sits on a manageable lot with spectacular water views looking north over West Harbor and into Fishers Island Sound. This winterized ho...

View this property >>

MYSTIC ISLE REALTY

Developed Properties