Fishers Island Real Estate - Mystic Isle Realty, Inc.

Cottage E

Mansion Hill

Mansion Hill A quintessential shingled style summer cottage. Built circa 1903, and while reta ining its original character, architectural features and overall original design, Cottage E has been well maintained...

View this property >>

Hurricane Cove Cottage

West End, Dock, Private

Hurricane Cove Cottage West End, Private Location with Dock With elevated water views over Pirates Cove, West Harbor and Fis // --> hers Island Sound, this well- maintained...

View this property >>

Barleyfield

East End and near the Club

BARLEYFIELD FISHERS ISLAND, NEW YORK This very manageable and well maintained home enjoys one of the premier locations at the East End of the Island. Located within walking distance of the Big Club, with ele...

View this property >>

New Price

9.87 acres, 5,000+ sq. ft house Near Isabella

Unique Compound Isabella Beach Road Located on a 9.87 acre parcel of land which consists of four lots with the house sitting on the largest lot at 6.21 acres. The property has great privacy, ready access to Isabell...

View this property >>

Chocomount Beach Property

What a setting.

Chocomount Beach House Expansive Beachfront on Block Island Sound Fishers Island, New York Perhaps the premier waterfront location on Fishers Island, this 3.96+/- acre parcel with 322 feet of direct access to the east end of ...

View this property >>

West Harbor with a Dock

Ideal Location

On West Harbor with a Dock Located on West Harbor this fully renovated house sits on a manageable lot with spectacular water views looking north over West Harbor and into Fishers Island Sound. This winterized ho...

View this property >>

MiShack

West End Near Town

MiShack West End Property A wonderful cottage located near town across from the “Duck Pond”. The first floor has two large living rooms, a large kitchen with a breakfast area, and o...

View this property >>

East End, Land and Waterfront

Dock, garden, Observatory

Magnificent Property This elegant 5000 +/-sq.ft. home, situated on 11.4 acres, has a private beach, a 120-ft. dock and more than 600 feet of frontage onWest Harbor. Much of the main house enjoys commanding views l...

View this property >>

East End

Private, pool, 6 bedrooms

This is a very unique property located on 2.9 acres off the Brooks Point road. This fantastic six bedroom house has a nice formal dining room and a spacious living room with a fireplace and distant views of Fishers Isl...

View this property >>

West End - Central Location

Year round house

Alpine Avenue Located in the West End on a quite street that is behind the library and Catholic Church this new listing is near town, yet removed. The house has 2-3 bedrooms and two bathrooms and is fully winterized and ...

View this property >>

West End Five Bedrooms

Winterized and on Winthrop Drive

WEST END This five bedroom winterized home is located on approximately half an acre on secluded and tree lined Winthrop Drive. The 2800 sq. foot house includes a renovated eat in country kitchen with modern appliances ...

View this property >>

Undeveloped Lot

East End and near the gate house

The Best of both Worlds 2.93 acres on the East End yet near the West End This is a very interesting large lot that has terrific potential. The lot is large enough for one to make a very private dwelling. I ...

View this property >>

East End Lot

Clay Point Rd

CLAY POINT ROAD UNDEVELOPED BUILDING SITE This 2.52 acre building site in one of the most desirable areas of the East End is being offered for sale at $480,000 with annual taxes of approximately $1200. This wooded ...

View this property >>

MYSTIC ISLE REALTY

Developed Properties

Undeveloped Properties